To Intervene or Not to Intervene—The Daily Parenting Question

What do you do when you hear the kids ramping up for either a good old-fashioned fight or a too-much-fun hullabaloo?  The former usually ends with broken things and angry kids.  The latter usually ends with broken kids and angry parents. 

I have a few standard responses.  I holler from the bottom of the stairs, or I might march to the playroom and ask, “What’s going on?” If I’m yelling from the other room, I get the same volume answer: “Nothing!” If I’m in the same room, I am blessed with wide-eyed innocent faces coupled with the same answer.

Another common response I give is cautionary or corrective words. “Be sweet!” “Calm down, please!” To this, the kids might yell that they are being sweet or calming with zero discernable change in behavior. Or they may take the opportunity to highlight someone else’s misbehavior.

We still end up with something getting broken and someone getting angry. Well, I have discovered a new tactic that is—so far—working like magic. Are you ready for my brilliance?

Now when I hear muffled or maniacal laughter or an escalating argument I say, with a smile in my voice, “Do you need my help?” Oh, folks!  This is a game-changer in my house!

First, this builds our golden goal of attachment because my offer is a desirable thing; I am coming to help rather than correct or scold.  It’s good for all of us to remember that.

Second, the girls can conduct a self-assessment and decide if an adult is needed. This pause in their activity seems to be enough to regulate their bodies.

Third, I think there is a surprise psychological component to this tactic. I imagine sets of eyes meeting across the room, and the prisoner’s dilemma comes to life. I’m approximately half-joking about that.

The girls have asked for help and have declined my offer with this tactic, and both ways qualify as a win.  When I go to help, we are all unified in seeking a solution rather than blaming or feeling shame.  If I don’t help, I hear the narration of them working out the issue and I am so proud of them gaining negotiating and peace-making skills.

How do you de-escalate kids getting too rowdy? How successful is it?